Independent Est. MMXXVI
Latest PR News · Reviews · Culture

Latest PR

Reviews

Structured tasting notes from named writers — never a verdict on fewer than three cigars from one box.

News Reviews Culture
CAO Brazilia Review: One Brazilian Leaf, the Rest Is Nicaragua
8 min read

CAO Brazilia Review: One Brazilian Leaf, the Rest Is Nicaragua

Reviews: The CAO Brazilia wears a Brazilian wrapper over an all-Nicaraguan core. What it tastes like, whether it's worth buying, and why I won't score it.

Read article →
Nicaragua Supplies 64% of America's Premium Cigars. The Tatuaje Havana VI Is the Everyday One Worth Keeping.
9 min read

Nicaragua Supplies 64% of America's Premium Cigars. The Tatuaje Havana VI Is the Everyday One Worth Keeping.

Reviews: A Tatuaje Havana VI review across five sticks from one box, and whether Pete Johnson's everyday Nicaraguan blend still earns a rebuy at eleven bucks.

Read article →
Is the Oliveros Gran Retorno Worth $30 for Twenty? I Smoked a Dozen to Find Out
9 min read

Is the Oliveros Gran Retorno Worth $30 for Twenty? I Smoked a Dozen to Find Out

Reviews: An Oliveros Gran Retorno review at a buck and a half a stick. What twenty Nicaraguan bundle cigars really deliver, and where the bargain quits.

Read article →
The Cheaper Oliva Serie V Is the One I Rebuy, Not the Melanio
12 min read

The Cheaper Oliva Serie V Is the One I Rebuy, Not the Melanio

Reviews: Oliva Serie V vs Melanio, three from each box, tasted side by side. Which Nicaraguan blend earns the extra dollars, and when the cheaper one wins.

Read article →
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Review: From a Miami Shop to 20 Million Cigars a Year
12 min read

My Father Le Bijou 1922 Review: From a Miami Shop to 20 Million Cigars a Year

Reviews: My Father Le Bijou 1922 review of the Nicaraguan puro that took the Garcia family from a Miami shop to Esteli, and whether it still earns the box.

Read article →
Is the El Rey del Mundo Robusto Worth a Box? Six Years In, I Keep Reaching for It
9 min read

Is the El Rey del Mundo Robusto Worth a Box? Six Years In, I Keep Reaching for It

Reviews: The El Rey del Mundo Robusto isn't a special-occasion cigar. It's the Honduran value box I keep reaching for - and here's why it earns the shelf.

Read article →
The Aganorsa Supreme Leaf Robusto Earns Its Name. Here's How, Third by Third.
9 min read

The Aganorsa Supreme Leaf Robusto Earns Its Name. Here's How, Third by Third.

Reviews: Five Aganorsa Supreme Leaf Robustos from one box, walked cold draw to nub. Why this $9 Nicaraguan corojo out-smokes the premium shelf.

Read article →
Four Gordos, One Box, One Honest Number: The Perdomo 30th Anniversary Maduro, Reviewed
11 min read

Four Gordos, One Box, One Honest Number: The Perdomo 30th Anniversary Maduro, Reviewed

Reviews: Four Perdomo 30th Anniversary Maduro Gordos from one box - the four-pass tasting, an honest rating, and where it lands against the Padrón 1964.

Read article →
Fuente OpusX Review: Is the Unicorn Worth the Hunt?
12 min read

Fuente OpusX Review: Is the Unicorn Worth the Hunt?

Reviews: A Fuente OpusX review that skips the worship. Four myths about the unicorn cigar, what the hunt really costs, and when it's worth your money.

Read article →
My Father La Lealtad Review: A Torpedo That Trades Power for Polish, Made in Honduras
12 min read

My Father La Lealtad Review: A Torpedo That Trades Power for Polish, Made in Honduras

Reviews: My Father La Lealtad review of the box-pressed torpedo, a Garcia blend that trades Nicaraguan power for polish and ships from Honduras, not Esteli.

Read article →
Does the Davidoff Late Hour Robusto Earn Its Whisky-Barrel Reputation?
9 min read

Does the Davidoff Late Hour Robusto Earn Its Whisky-Barrel Reputation?

Reviews: I smoked four Davidoff Late Hour Robustos from a single box, third by third, to see whether the Scotch-cask aging earns its $20-plus price.

Read article →
A Four-Inch Perfecto That Keeps Selling Out: An Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Review
8 min read

A Four-Inch Perfecto That Keeps Selling Out: An Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Review

Reviews: why the Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story, a four-inch Cameroon perfecto, keeps selling out, how it smokes, and whether it earns the hype.

Read article →
Four Decades In, the Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Still Outsells Fuente's New Releases
11 min read

Four Decades In, the Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Still Outsells Fuente's New Releases

News: The Arturo Fuente Don Carlos review nobody writes - why a 40-year-old Cameroon blend outsells Fuente's new releases, and what the FDA ruling changed.

Read article →
Is the Rocky Patel Year of the Horse a Lunar New Year Gimmick, or a Real Smoke?
11 min read

Is the Rocky Patel Year of the Horse a Lunar New Year Gimmick, or a Real Smoke?

Reviews: Three Rocky Patel Year of the Horse cigars from one box, smoked over a week: the burn trouble, the espresso-and-caramel arc, and whether it earns its billing.

Read article →
Oliva Serie V Melanio Robusto: It Outperforms Its Own Toro
10 min read

Oliva Serie V Melanio Robusto: It Outperforms Its Own Toro

Reviews: Three boxes of the Oliva Serie V Melanio Robusto across six months - where it sits in the line, where the burn went wrong, and the buy call.

Read article →
Liga Privada No. 9 Review: Is the Broadleaf Bully Still Worth Chasing?
10 min read

Liga Privada No. 9 Review: Is the Broadleaf Bully Still Worth Chasing?

Reviews: A Liga Privada No. 9 review across five sticks from one box - cold draw to nub, one plugged draw, and an honest buy, age or skip verdict.

Read article →
25 Cigars, 14 Months, One Taste: A Padrón 1964 Anniversary Maduro Review
10 min read

25 Cigars, 14 Months, One Taste: A Padrón 1964 Anniversary Maduro Review

Reviews: A padron 1964 anniversary review built on one full box - 25 cigars over 14 months, what consistency is really worth, and the maduro verdict.

Read article →